Protecting Migrants from Ill-Treatment in Detention

By Abigail Oliver, REDRESS Legal Fellow

Content note: This article discusses suicide.

A complaint of police ill-treatment and torture at Barcelona’s Zona Franca immigration detention centre is before the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR). In Zaidan v Spain, the Court is considering Mohammed Zaidan’s allegations that police officers assaulted and restrained him at an immigration detention centre, and that the authorities failed to provide appropriate medical care in the aftermath. 

REDRESS submitted a third-party intervention addressing the European and international standards on the use of force, particularly as applied against vulnerable persons in detention. 

The case comes amid growing concerns about Europe’s treatment of migrants. Following the EU Migration and Asylum Pact’s entry into application in June 2026, civil society organisations have warned of longer detention periods and increased risks for torture survivors. The EU Agency for Fundamental Rights has also raised concerns about violence against migrants, while UN Committees have highlighted the heightened risks of abuse faced by migrants with disabilities. Mr Zaidan’s case brings these concerns into sharp focus.

The Case 

Mohammed Zaidan was held at the Zona Franca immigration detention centre in Barcelona. He alleges that, on 12 January 2020, he was denied his prescribed nightly medication and threw a yoghurt on the floor in a moment of anxiety.

According to his account, a police officer then punched him in the neck, dragged him down the stairs, and restrained him by pressing a knee against his neck. He was taken to the infirmary and later returned to his room. That evening, he tried to take his life. After receiving medication but no psychological assistance, he was placed in isolation. The incident left him with redness on his neck and significant psychological harm.

Mr Zaidan filed an internal complaint the next day. The Spanish courts subsequently closed the criminal proceedings, finding insufficient evidence to send the officers for trial, and Mr Zaidan was initially deported before he could testify. He subsequently brought his complaint to the ECtHR, represented by the human rights NGO Iridia.

REDRESS’ Intervention 

As an independent intervener, REDRESS submitted written comments in Zaidan v Spain addressing the unlawful use of force against people in detention, particularly where migration-related and mental health vulnerabilities overlap. REDRESS’ intervention underscores a fundamental limit on State power: immigration control does not weaken the prohibition of torture and other ill-treatment. Neither a person’s immigration status nor their distress or mental health vulnerability makes unnecessary force permissible. 

Unnecessary Force is Prohibited by Article 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights  

Assessing the use of force against people in detention must consider whether force was strictly necessary, rather than simply whether it caused serious injuries. People in detention are under the control and care of the State, which means that authorities are held to strict standards when using force.  

Drawing on the Court’s landmark judgment in Bouyid v Belgium, in which REDRESS also intervened, REDRESS submitted that force used against someone in State custody, where their own conduct does not make it necessary, violates their dignity and, in principle, constitutes a violation of Article 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights, which prohibits torture and inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment.  

Scrutiny of the use of force in detention often focuses on the injuries it leaves behind, such as the red mark on  Mr Zaidan’s neck and the psychological harm he suffered. But a person does not have to prove lasting injury or intense suffering for unnecessary force to amount to ill-treatment. The absence of visible injuries does not make unnecessary force acceptable. Humiliation, fear, and powerlessness can themselves constitute harm. Being struck or subjected to unjustified restraint, such as isolation while under the control of officials, can, in itself, amount to degrading treatment. 

In practice, this means that authorities must justify both the use of force and its duration. Even where restraint is initially necessary, this does not justify continuing it once the danger has passed. Where several techniques are used together, the assessment should consider the combined effects. Force cannot be used as punishment for resistance, perceived disrespect, or an officer’s frustration.  

Vulnerability Calls for Additional Care, Not Force 

Confusion or agitation may indicate that someone needs medical assistance and a response adapted to their circumstances. It is not give a blanket license to use force. Language barriers, prior trauma, and mental health conditions can heighten the vulnerability inherent in detention. People in detention depend on staff for medication, care, and safety. Mr Zaidan, for example, could not obtain his prescribed medication independently. Because of this vulnerability, States must safeguard detainees’ health and well-being, including by providing adequate medical and psychological assistance. Simply seeing a doctor, receiving medication, or receiving medical assessments does not necessarily fulfill its obligation if the care provided fails to address the individual’s actual needs.  

Following self-harm, protective measures must come with appropriate assessment, supervision, and appropriate treatment. Staff training, effective communication, and the availability of less intrusive responses are therefore important considerations when assessing whether the use of force was necessary in the first place. Restraint must not replace appropriate care. 

Why It Matters 

Everyone, including people in detention, is entitled to dignity, protection, and care. Immigration detention must not become punitive in practice. Authorities must be able to explain why any force used was strictly necessary. Zaidan offers the ECtHR an opportunity to reaffirm the absolute prohibition of torture and other ill-treatment, particularly for people with mental health needs and other vulnerabilities.

Photo by: Medol/ Wikimedia commons