Varnava and Others v. Turkey (third party intervention)
In the summer of 1974, nine Greek-Cypriot soldiers disappeared during a battle with the Turkish military. Reported sightings of the soldiers in Turkish prisons, the discovery of remains in a mass grave, and the refusal of the Turkish government to investigate the fates and whereabouts has led to the belief that the soldiers were forcibly disappeared.
CASE BACKGROUND
The case concerns the disappearance of nine Greek-Cypriot soldiers during Turkish military operations in Northern Cyprus from July to August 1974. To date, Turkey has not released any information on their fates or whereabouts.
The Applicants, who were relatives of the disappeared soldiers, lodged a complaint before the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) in 1990 regarding Turkey’s failure to investigate the disappearances. The Applicants argued that their ongoing uncertainty and mental distress from the refusal of Turkish authorities to investigate the disappearance of their relatives amounted to inhuman treatment under Article 3 of the European Convention of Human Rights (ECHR). They also alleged violations of Article 2 (right to life) and Article 5 (right to liberty).
The Third Section of the ECtHR found procedural violations of Articles 2 and 5 for Turkey’s failure to investigate and a substantive violation of Article 3 for the distress caused to relatives. However, the Third Section ruled that the judgement was a sufficient form of reparation. The Applicants referred the case to the Grand Chamber of the ECtHR.
INTERVENTION
REDRESS submitted a third-party intervention to the Grand Chamber on 2 October 2008. The intervention is available here.
In the intervention, REDRESS argued that a favourable judgement does not constitute just satisfaction, citing international jurisprudence on the obligation to make reparation. The intervention also positioned enforced disappearance as a continuing violation requiring continuing remedies. REDRESS encouraged the Grand Chamber to align its interpretation of the ECHR with the recently adopted International Convention for the Protection of All Persons from Enforced Disappearance and advocated for the award of just satisfaction measures to end existing violations and prevent future violations.
CASE OUTCOME
The Grand Chamber reached a decision on 18 September 2009, finding there was significant evidence of detention in the cases of two of the nine missing men and thus a continuing violation of Article 5 (not just a procedural violation). The Court confirmed that:
- States have an obligation to investigate the disappearance of citizens and failure to do so amounts to a violation of Article 5;
- Family members of the disappeared may be viewed as victims of Article 3 as a result of the mental distress of not knowing their relatives’ fate and whereabouts.
The Grand Chamber also issued reparation for non-pecuniary (non-financial) damages to the Applicants, amounting to EUR 12,000 per Applicant.
The case is regarded as a leading authority on enforced disappearances in European human rights law, establishing them as ongoing violations that require just satisfaction.
The decision can be found here and can be cited as follows: Varnava and Others v. Turkey, Apps Nos 16064/90, 16065/90, 16066/90, 16068/90, 16069/90, 16070/90, 16071/90, 16072/90 and 16073/90 (ECtHR, 18 September 2009).
QUICK FACTS
Case name: Varnava and Others v. Turkey
Court/Body: European Court of Human Rights, Grand Chamber
Date intervention filed: 25 January 1990
Current status: Decision reached.
Date of final decision: 18 September 2009
KEY WORDS
- Enforced disappearance is when a person is arrested, detained, abducted or otherwise deprived of their liberty by State agents (or with their support) followed by authorities’ refusal to acknowledge this or reveal the person’s fate or whereabouts.
- Just satisfaction is the remedy awarded by the ECtHR under Article 41 of the European Convention. It acts as a form of financial compensation or damages given to a person whose rights have been violated if local laws are unable to provide reparation.
- The Grand Chamber is the highest judicial body of the ECtHR.